How will Labour ever be relevant again?
August 11th, 2010
Over dinner on Monday with a friend who happens to also be a senior Tory, and an admitted ‘huge fan’ of the Coalition Government, I found myself wondering about how the Labour Party might one day find its way back to government. I found it hard to stomach but my Tory friend’s argument was that the 2015 general election will be a battle between the Labour Party one one side and the Coalition on the other. The technicalities of this I haven’t got my head around, and I still think it could go one of many ways, but this should worry and concern the Labour Party.
My first answer to this point was that, David Cameron clearly having proven his ability to grab and hold on to power, is a ruthless political operator and wouldn’t hesitate to end the coalition deal and govern alone as a Conservative government, presumably if the Conservatives win more seats in 2015. I know it’s fashionable in Labour circles to write off the possibility that there will be a Tory Prime Minister for two terms, but single-term governments in the UK are very rare and by 2015, as painful as it might be, the deficit will be gone and it will be time to dish out the rewards and bribes to the electorate. So assuming David Cameron wins in 2015, why wouldn’t he end the Coalition in favour of an outright Tory government?
The answer is simple. Being in a coalition means Cameron can keep the Tory party as close to the centre as he likes. The Tories need to compromise so they can keep power. Of course if they had their own majority that could change but by all accounts the Coalition is now formed of three parts: 1) left-leaning Liberal Democrats who aren’t vastly comfortable with the setup, 2) right-leaning Tories who aren’t vastly comfortable with the setup either & 3) the real Coalition, the collection of Ministers & Cabinet Secretaries, and the majority of Lib/Con MPs who fully support the setup and the new way of doing politics.
It’s easy to brush the Coalition off as a right-wing government in disguise, but we just have to remember more financially rosy times and look at the approach that David Cameron wanted to take to governing. As far as Tories go, he is a centrist. He’s the ‘heir to Blair’ remember, and proud of it no doubt. Cameron is no Margaret Thatcher. So if we imagine for a moment that Cameron is a true centrist, a logical step would be to forge a permanent coalition, similar to what it looks now, into a centrist party on its own. The Liberal Democrats are in a precarious position, that is abundantly clear, with a recent poll suggesting that if an election were called today that their seat count would be reduced to just 13. Who would Nick Clegg be in that position to say no to forming a new, centrist party with a senior position for him and even a shot at being Prime Minister himself in five or ten years?
So where does this leave the Labour Party? It is hard to say but it would be naive to think that we will simply march back into Number 10 Downing Street in May 2015, simply because of ‘the cuts’ or because the population will see the ‘true colours’ of the Coalition. The Coalition is quite popular out there, as Ed Miliband and others have said, people like seeing a new way in British politics. Labour’s thus far short stint in opposition has been lacklustre and disappointing. I feel a slight shift to the left even from the more right-leaning leadership candidates. Be sure of this: for Labour to get anywhere near forming another government, it needs to genuinely renew itself, decide what it is about and make itself distinct to the electorate.
Heading to the intellectual comfort zone of the left will make Labour even more irrelevant than it currently is. Banking on the Coalition being unpopular enough in 2015 to turn around Labour’s fortunes is lazy and won’t work.
So how do we in the Labour Party re-gain the momentum to be the party of government once more? Will the Coalition become permanent and what would that mean to Labour’s fortunes over the next decade or two?
“May you live in interesting times” is a Chinese curse. These are most certainly interesting times for anybody in or interesting in politics.

I live in London. I have two young daughters, four and two years old, and I thought that growing up in the capital would give them a unique perspective on life and a different type of self-assurance that feeling at home somewhere as incredible as London can give you. When my mum moved us from South Wales to Brixton in 1999, we lived in one of the worst housing estates in the country. As much as I love the heart and soul of Brixton – it is one of the few places in this city with its own genuine soul – it was a tough time as a teenager living there, and I was determined that when I had children we would live in a leafier, more gentle part of town.











